He doesn't contribute anything to the show, except being indirectly responsible for the creation of Tibbles.

It seems that many people forget that Tibbles is important for the story because he was the one who found the Azura books in the demon realm, leading to Lumity having their biggest shared interest

Though the fact that Tinella Nosa and Matt Tholomule were helping him doesn't make sense because they should have no reason to be associated with him.

Though the fact that Tinella Nosa and Matt Tholomule were helping him doesn't make sense because they should have no reason to be associated with him.

Tinella for funny

And Matt because that's something he'd do

they should have no reason to be associated with him.

Their reason was

Well, based on their previous appearances, they should have no reason to be associated with one another.

I don’t like Tibbles but I wouldn’t say he was a “huge mistake”, he had his role in the story as a recurring side villain and he fulfilled it well.

I do find the fact he's a literal capitalistic pig funny. also why is a character being hated bad he's a villain we should hate him

I don't like Tibbles. His voice sounds off and even Sarah-Nicole Robles hates him.

Tibbles is a huge mistake. I mean he contributed to nothing. Him and Matt never brought Amity and Luz together.

Maybe Tinella Nosa, but Tibbles and Matt never brought Lumity together nor did they make that happen.

Lumity happened on its own between Luz and Amity because of Luz's positive influence on Amity and how Amity saw Luz as someone who saved her from the life she wasn't happy with.

Their shared interest had nothing to do with Tibbles or Matt. I was at first assuming Tinella Nosa did at some point.