I'd recommend it, it's always a nice trip down memory lane. Although I still fondly remember the times when it was airing, can't believe it's been so long.

I remember when after both "For the Future" and "Watching and Dreaming" came out there'd be a dedicated spoilers thread for the episode, and no spoilers were allowed outside of it! Good times.

I'm thinking of rewatching it this summer so I can replace my old cringe memories of this show with newer, more fun ones

You guys are so lucky that you watched the show without spoilers, I started the show almost 2 years after it ended and almost everything was spoiled, I knew Luz dies in watching and dreaming even before I finished episode 5 and I knew the entire Belos is Philip before I was halfway through season 2. And I knew king's tide ending even before I met the collector. This is because I saw pictures or my school friends straight up assumed I finished the show and told me spoilers